Independent MTG Proxy Reviews
Compare proxy printing companies by overall score, recommendation, testing history, and the type of order each service handles best.
Showing 1 to 12 of 38 companies
Best Overall Value for Commander Decks and Bulk MTG Proxies
Company Overview ProxyFoundry is a U.S.-based print-on-demand service specializing in Magic: The Gathering proxy cards for Commander, Cube, casual gameplay, […]
Best for: Complete 100-card Commander decks, Multiple Commander decks in one order, Cube owners ordering hundreds of cards
Best for bulk orders and commander decks
ProxyMTG is a U.S.-based, MTG-specific print-on-demand service built around card search, decklist importing, and quantity pricing for Commander decks, Cubes, and larger playtest orders.
Best for: Complete 100-card Commander decks, Multiple Commander deck orders, Cube projects
Best Overall Balance of Quality, Tools, and Price
PrintMTG is a provider of print-on-demand MTG proxy cards. They have a slick website that allows users to paste in […]
Best for: First-time proxy buyers, Custom Commander decks, Alternate-art cards
Best for Premium Singles and Physical Card Quality
Best for: Original or properly licensed card projects, Orders of approximately 200 cards or more, Advanced buyers with print-ready artwork
Strong individual cards, weak consistency and fulfillment
Best for: Specific printings unavailable from other sellers, Newer foil and etched-foil cards, Expensive Commander and cEDH staples
Rising prices, declining value, and serious fulfillment concerns Copy
Best for: Existing customers who remain satisfied with recent orders, Buyers specifically seeking partial-foil customization, Customers who value MPCFill and Google Drive importing
We do not recommend
Proxy Ninja operates MTGProxies.biz as a catalog retailer of replica-style MTG cards. It sells prepared singles, foils, themed sets, tokens, and specialty cards rather than printing customer-submitted decklists or artwork. The company offers tracked domestic and international shipping, but its original-style backs, absent proxy markings, and selected holograms place it in the replica-style product category rather than the clearly marked playtest-card category.
Overpriced proxies with disappointing print quality and better alternatives Copy
PrintingProxies is an established MTG and TCG proxy printing service offering searchable card catalogs, decklist importing, custom artwork, and specialty foil options. Although its website and ordering tools are convenient, our hands-on evaluations found disappointing print quality, below-average card construction, and poor value compared with stronger competitors. The company has also faced controversy over alleged fake promotional reviews and bans from multiple Reddit communities.
Best for: Existing customers already satisfied with the product, Buyers who strongly prefer its ordering interface, Customers requiring a specific supported language or customization option
Black Lotus MTG proxies, commonly sold under the BL name, come from a long-running Shenzhen-based replica-style card seller now operating through Magic Cardplus. The catalog includes regular, holo, and foil singles, curated sets, quantity discounts, and worldwide shipping.
Bootleg Mage is a U.S.-based reseller of replica-style MTG singles, including standard, foil, foreign-language, retro, and specialty-finish versions. It operates as an inventory-based reseller with a searchable catalog rather than a custom print-on-demand service. The seller has publicly stated that roughly 70 percent of the shop was sourced from USea.
Cardmire was a U.S.-based replica-style MTG seller, formerly known as Proxyhaus, best known for early Power Nine, dual land, and other high-value reproductions. Its dedicated MTG storefront appears to have stopped operating by early 2019, although the Cardmire Etsy account remains active with unrelated collectible comics.
