Proxy Ninja

Catalog-Based Replica Card Retailer

Proxy Ninja operates MTGProxies.biz and sells prepared Magic reproduction cards from a fixed inventory. It is not a print-on-demand service. The company’s published shop policy says it does not accept custom card orders, so buyers must choose from cards already listed in the catalog.

The store sells individual cards, foil versions, themed sets, random proxy packs, tokens, gold cards, and selected specialty treatments. Some double-sided products are also available.

Search And Ordering

Proxy Ninja provides a searchable catalog and an advanced search page with filters for product name, rules text, card color, card type, foil status, and price. This is useful when looking for a particular prepared version.

The ordering system does not include a decklist importer, custom artwork upload, custom card creator, or automated Commander deck workflow. Every card must already exist in the store’s inventory.

Pricing

Proxy Ninja uses individual product pricing rather than a standard quantity-based rate. As of July 24, 2026, many ordinary singles were listed between approximately $1.25 and $7.75, while selected foil and specialty cards reached approximately $10 or more. The store also sells themed sets and random proxy packs.

This pricing model is better suited to a small number of prepared singles than a complete Commander deck or large Cube. The company does not publish a conventional bulk-pricing schedule.

Shipping And Fulfillment

The FAQ says orders ship within three to five business days. The shop policy instead says orders ship within three business days through tracked USPS First Class mail. The company appears to offer both domestic and international shipping.

The home page currently advertises free United States shipping on orders of $100 or more. Promotions and shipping thresholds may change, so buyers should confirm the current terms before ordering.

Published Return Policy

Proxy Ninja limits refunds to damaged cards, incorrect cards, or the wrong card version. The company says it does not provide refunds for most other reasons. Cancellation requests must be submitted within 24 hours, and orders that have already shipped must be returned in their original condition before a refund is issued.

The published policy describes refunds rather than guaranteed defect reprints or a broad satisfaction guarantee.

Product Classification

Proxy Ninja belongs in the replica-style product category. The company says its cards use original-style Magic backs, do not include visible proxy markings, and may include recessed holograms on selected products. Those features make the cards more likely to be confused with authentic products than clearly marked playtest cards.

Replica-style cards should never be sold or represented as genuine Magic cards. Buyers should keep them clearly separated from authentic collections and use them only in settings where all participants understand what they are.

Company Claims And Verification

Proxy Ninja says its cards are professionally printed on German black-core cardstock and are designed to resemble authentic cards in feel and handling. Those are company-provided claims. The linked review identifies which conclusions are based on website research, customer reports, or independent testing.

PRIVATE DATABASE NOTES Active catalog-based replica-style retailer operating MTGProxies.biz. The company’s published policy says it does not accept custom orders. Its About page says cards use original-style Magic backs, do not include proxy markings, and may include recessed holograms. The store offers singles, foils, sets, packs, tokens, and specialty variants, but no decklist importer, custom uploads, or deck-scale ordering workflow. The FAQ lists three to five business days before shipment, while the shop policy says orders ship within three business days. Refunds are limited to damaged, incorrect, or wrong-version cards. The privacy policy contained unfinished template placeholders as of July 24, 2026. Historical community discussion under “The Proxy Ninja” dates to 2017. The linked review remains research-only and unscored pending an anonymous purchase and physical inspection.